13F-HR 1 pzenainvestmentmg13fhr20913.txt HOLDINGS REPORT UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549 FORM 13F FORM 13F Cover Page Report for the Calendar Year or Quarter Ended: September 30, 2005 PZENA INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, LLC -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name of Institutional Investment Manager 120 West 45th Street, 20th Floor NY NY 10036 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Business Address (Street) (City) (State) (Zip) 13F File Number: 28-03791 -------------------- The Institutional Investment Manager filing this report and the person by whom it is signed hereby represent that the person signing the report is authorized to submit it, and that all information contained herein is true, correct and complete, and that it is understood that all required items, statements, schedules, and tables are considered integral parts of this form. Name, Title and Telephone Number of Person Submitting Report: Richard S. Pzena Manager (212) 355-1600 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name (Title) (Phone) Signature, Place and Date of Signing: /s/ Richard S. Pzena ---------------------------------- Richard S. Pzena Pzena Investment Management, LLC 120 West 45th Street, 20th Floor New York, New York 10036 11/11/05 Report Type: [X] 13F HOLDINGS REPORT [ ] 13F NOTICE [ ] 13F COMBINATION REPORT FORM 13F SUMMARY PAGE Number of Other Included Managers: None ------------ Form 13F Information Table Entry Total: 105 ----------- Form 13F Information Table Value Total: $14,417,614,000 -------------------------- DISCRETIONARY OWNERSHIP FOR 13F AS OF DATE: 9/30/2005 Name of Reporting Manager: Pzena Investment Management, LLC

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ITEM 1 ITEM 2 ITEM 3 ITEM 4 ITEM 5 ITEM 6 ITEM 7 ITEM 8 VALUE SHARES INVSTMT OTHER VOTING AUTHORITY NAME OF ISSUER TITLE OF CLASS CUSIP (x$1000) PRN AMT DSCRETN MANAGERS SOLE SHARED NONE ------------------------------ ---------------- --------- -------- --------- ------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- 1ST CITIZENS BK Com 31946M103 12265 71870 71870 0 59070 0 12800 AFTERMARKET TECHNOLOGY CORP Com 008318107 21078 1146155 1146155 0 960233 0 185922 ALLSTATE CORP Com 020002101 249765 4517360 4517360 0 2535005 0 1982355 ALTRIA GROUP INC Com 02209S103 24796 336400 336400 0 19575 0 316825 AMER NATL INS Com 028591105 22411 188142 188142 0 163267 0 24875 AMERICAN HOME MORTGAGE Com 02660R107 29913 987225 987225 0 852700 0 134525 AMERICAN PHYSICIANS CAPIT Com 028884104 8044 163725 163725 0 147200 0 16525 AMERISOURCEBERGEN CORP Com 3073E108 377699 4886150 4886150 0 2864600 0 2021550 AMERUS GROUP Com 03072M108 25303 441050 441050 0 375850 0 65200 AON CORP Com 037389103 393273 12259135 12259135 0 7139935 0 5119200 ARVINMERITOR INC Com 043353101 40361 2413910 2413910 0 2053085 0 360825 ASHLAND INC Com 044209104 97915 1772545 1772545 0 1345520 0 427025 AUTOZONE INC. Com 053332102 229893 2761475 2761475 0 1391500 0 1369975 BANK OF AMERICA CORP Com 060505104 2984 70875 70875 0 59500 0 11375 BAXTER INTL Com 071813109 474 11900 11900 0 11900 0 0 BEARINGPOINT INC. Com 074002106 20410 2689025 2689025 0 2298175 0 390850 BOEING COMPANY Com 097023105 385665 5675711 5675711 0 2911653 0 2764058 BOWNE & CO Com 103043105 48704 3408250 3408250 0 3067375 0 340875 BP PLC ADR Com 055622104 135963 1919020 1919020 0 692270 0 1226750 BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB CO Com 110122108 298273 12397057 12397057 0 5455707 0 6941350 CAROLINA GROUP/LOEWS Com 540424207 17541 442625 442625 0 421975 0 20650 CIBER INC. Com 17163B102 39821 5359450 5359450 0 4694400 0 665050 CIGNA Com 125509109 113627 964086 964086 0 187711 0 776375 CIT GROUP INC Com 125581108 282498 6252727 6252727 0 3075552 0 3177175 CITIGROUP INC Com 172967101 500371 10992335 10992335 0 5278702 0 5713633 COMERICA INC Com 200340107 259951 4413425 4413425 0 1994125 0 2419300 COMMSCOPE INC Com 203372107 14978 863775 863775 0 691850 0 171925 COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTL Com 204912109 425320 15293767 15293767 0 7819085 0 7474682 COMPUTER SCIENCES Com 205363104 307565 6501050 6501050 0 2980325 0 3520725 CONOCOPHILLIPS Com 20825C104 16569 237000 237000 0 49300 0 187700 DEL MONTE FOODS Com 24522P103 42673 3976999 3976999 0 3532749 0 444250 DELPHI FINL GRP Com 247131105 32491 694261 694261 0 615849 0 78412 DEX MEDIA Com 25212E104 139069 5004271 5004271 0 3801121 0 1203150 FANNIE MAE Com 313586109 488945 10909091 10909091 0 5529241 0 5379850 FIRST AMERICAN CORP Com 318522307 206368 4518670 4518670 0 3515295 0 1003375 FMC CORP Com 302491303 69217 1209664 1209664 0 851701 0 357963 FMC TECHNOLOGIES Com 30249U101 23904 567667 567667 0 206351 0 361316 FREDDIE MAC Com 313400301 498944 8837129 8837129 0 4540829 0 4296300 GENERAL CABLE CORP DEL NE Com 369300108 562 33450 33450 0 33450 0 0 GLENBOROUGH REALTY TRUST INC Com 37803P105 16374 852825 852825 0 729325 0 123500 GLOBAL IMAGING SYSTEMS INC Com 37934A100 14175 416296 416296 0 342771 0 73525 HANGER ORTHOPEDIC Com 41043F208 10688 1388100 1388100 0 1173925 0 214175 HASBRO INC Com 418056107 129912 6611295 6611295 0 5388781 0 1222514 HCA THE HEALTHCARE CO Com 404119109 95164 1985900 1985900 0 695850 0 1290050 HEALTH NET INC Com 42222G108 35866 757942 757942 0 545975 0 211967 HEWLETT PACKARD Com 428236103 472257 16173193 16173193 0 7692552 0 8480641 HORACE MANN EDUCATORS Com 440327104 30218 1527700 1527700 0 1302150 0 225550 HUB INTERNATIONAL LTD Com 44332P101 14309 630925 630925 0 504350 0 126575 IDACORP INC Com 451107106 22218 737391 737391 0 619141 0 118250 IPC HLDGS LTD Com G4933P101 159147 4874326 4874326 0 3894248 0 980078 JACKSON HEWITT TAX SERVICE INC. Com 468202106 9141 382300 382300 0 326200 0 56100 JANUS CAPITAL GROUP INC Com 47102X105 18175 1257814 1257814 0 1075839 0 181975 JOHNSON CONTROLS Com 478366107 456300 7353750 7353750 0 3610675 0 3743075 JP MORGAN CHASE & CO Com 46625H100 12462 367300 367300 0 330200 0 37100 KELLWOOD CO. Com 488044108 22534 871725 871725 0 728675 0 143050 KELLY SERVICES INC Com 488152208 23734 774100 774100 0 660125 0 113975 KENNAMETAL INC Com 489170100 47395 966464 966464 0 847889 0 118575 LAFARGE NORTH AMERICA Com 505862102 8155 120613 120613 0 120613 0 0 LEAR CORP Com 521865105 333520 9818062 9818062 0 7991467 0 1826595 LIBBEY INC Com 529898108 17554 1154850 1154850 0 968375 0 186475 LOEWS CORP Com 540424108 233846 2530525 2530525 0 936213 0 1594312 MAGNA INTL INC. Com 559222401 141032 1883950 1883950 0 720200 0 1163750 MAYTAG CORP Com 578592107 19362 1060325 1060325 0 917225 0 143100 MCKESSON CORPORATION Com 58155Q103 95992 2023020 2023020 0 531874 0 1491146 MERCER INSURANCE GROUP Com 587902107 477 36500 36500 0 36500 0 0 METLIFE INC Com 59156R108 482116 9675222 9675222 0 4792072 0 4883150 MICROSOFT CORP Com 594918104 330327 12838200 12838200 0 5603750 0 7234450 MILACRON INC Com 598709103 6744 3788876 3788876 0 3315226 0 473650 MONEYGRAM INTERNATIONAL INC Com 60935Y109 128435 5915940 5915940 0 4728230 0 1187710 MORGAN STANLEY Com 617446448 460127 8530350 8530350 0 4203625 0 4326725 MYERS INDUSTRIES INC Com 628464109 5315 456600 456600 0 280025 0 176575 NACCO IND Com 629579103 23076 201625 201625 0 172050 0 29575 NBTY INC. Com 628782104 47325 2013850 2013850 0 1749325 0 264525 NCI BLDG SYS INC Com 628852105 55558 1362060 1362060 0 1230485 0 131575 OLD REPBLC INTL Com 680223104 116628 4373012 4373012 0 3278787 0 1094225 PETROL BRASILEIROS ADR Com 71654V408 253 3545 3545 0 3545 0 0 PFIZER INC Com 717081103 324187 12983040 12983040 0 6148990 0 6834050 PHH CORP Com 693320202 32041 1166835 1166835.3 0 902283 0 264552.25 PRIORITY HEALTHCARE Com 74264T102 47830 1716800 1716800 0 1593750 0 123050 PROTECTIVE LIFE CORP Com 743674103 8369 203239 203239 0 192064 0 11175 R H DONNELLEY Com 74955W307 10121 159984 159984 0 143559 0 16425 RADIOSHACK CORP Com 750438103 154945 6247775 6247775 0 2285550 0 3962225 RENAISSANCE RE HLDGS LTD Com G7496G103 115202 2634400 2634400 0 2001500 0 632900 RENT A CENTER INC Com 76009N100 153945 7972275 7972275 0 6353400 0 1618875 ROBBINS & MYERS Com 770196103 9258 411850 411850 0 360925 0 50925 SARA LEE CORP Com 803111103 436389 23028450 23028450 0 10322300 0 12706150 SCHWEITZER MAUDUIT INTL I Com 808541106 17578 787525 787525 0 710600 0 76925 SEMPRA ENERGY Com 816851109 211701 4498525 4498525 0 1956100 0 2542425 SPHERION CORPORATION Com 848420105 57481 7563350 7563350 0 6860525 0 702825 TJX COS INC NEW Com 872540109 456122 22271575 22271575 0 10787350 0 11484225 TOMMY HILFIGER CORP Com G8915Z102 192 11075 11075 0 11075 0 0 TORCHMARK CORP Com 891027104 465947 8819741 8819741 0 4408516 0 4411225 TRINITY IND Com 896522109 1532 37825 37825 0 35150 0 2675 UNION PAC CORP Com 907818108 474666 6620165 6620165 0 3187715 0 3432450 UNITED AMERICA INDEMNITY Com 90933T109 17695 964321 964321 0 822121 0 142200 UNITED STATIONERS INC Com 913004107 36093 754145 754145 0 654270 0 99875 UNIVERSAL CORP Com 913456109 24536 631882 631882 0 610132 0 21750 VALASSIS COMM Com 918866104 42296 1085079 1085079 0 957179 0 127900 VIAD CORP Com 92552R406 78560 2872408 2872408 0 2298498 0 573910 WASH MUTUAL INC Com 939322103 39208 999706 999706 0 693823 0 305883 WHIRLPOOL CORP Com 963320106 500185 6601354 6601354 0 3394179 0 3207175 WILLIAM MORRISON SUPERMARKETS Com 000604316 103 32766 32766 0 32766 0 0 WISCONSIN ENRGY Com 976657106 268424 6724060 6724060 0 3646585 0 3077475 XL CAPITAL LTD Com G98255105 429205 6309052 6309052 0 2944177 0 3364875 YORK INTL Com 986670107 2289 40820 40820 0 34845 0 5975